Tooth Fairy Monster Pillow for Boys and Girls with FREE Patterns

I was an avid ice hockey fan growing up, so when I was 7 years old and lost both my front teeth, I was super excited that my hero Bobby Clarke was missing his two front teeth as well! It was comforting and made everything a little less daunting. Little did I know at the time that his teeth were permanently missing from playing ice hockey. Yikes! Losing teeth can be kinda scary, so a fun Tooth Fairy Monster Pillow can be helpful in easing the kiddos into this transition. Inexpensive felt and a few buttons plus my favorite Poly-Fil® from Fairfield World make this project quick and easy.  I even created a free printable pattern to make this project even easier for you.

Tooth Fairy Monster Pillow for Boys and Girls with FREE Patterns Creatively Beth #creativelybeth #toothfairy #fairfieldworld #80daysofpolyfil #polyfil #felt #monster #craft

Quick and Easy Tooth Fairy Monster Pillows

This post, Tooth Fairy Monster Pillows for Boys and Girls with FREE Patterns, contains affiliate links. Using links to these sites means I will earn a percentage of the purchase at no extra cost to you.

Here’s what you need to make Tooth Fairy Pillows:

The lightweight, low-profile BrightPad makes crafting easier while reducing eye strain.

Here’s how to create Hand Sewn Monster Tooth Fairy Pillows:


Gather all supplies. Download, print and cut out Tooth Fairy Monster Pillow Patterns below.

Supplies needed for Tooth Fairy Monster Pillow for Boys and Girls with FREE Patterns Creatively Beth #creativelybeth #toothfairy #fairfieldworld #80daysofpolyfil #polyfil #felt #monster #craft


Layer two pieces of felt and entire tooth pattern together, securing with straight pins. Cut out with scissors. Repeat this process with tooth pocket pattern, eye patterns, and tooth patterns. Get the kiddos involved in this step by selecting their color scheme. Get creative and use up what you have on hand.


Attach white felt teeth to the back of the tooth pocket with hot glue. Repeat this process by attaching the felt eyes to the top of each monster body. I love the bold and bright super hero color combo, which is perfect for a boy or a girl!


Stack all three layers of felt together, lining up the edges and secure with straight pins. Thread an embroidery needle with floss and blanket stitch the edges, leaving a small two-inch opening at the top for stuffing. For step by step blanket stitch instructions, visit my friend Bev’s blog Flamingo Toes and her Embroidery Tips post, which is my go-to resource! I love the bright mix of contrasting colors.


Stuff the Tooth Fairy Monster Pillow with Poly-Fil® from Fairfield World™ through the small opening left at the top. Pull apart small pieces of Poly-Fil and work down into each section of the pillow using a chopstick or pencil. I like a soft stuff, so I use a bit less Poly-Fil. If you prefer a harder stuff, use more and pack it tighter.

Leave a section open and then stuff the Tooth Fairy Monster Pillow with Poly-Fil from Fairfield World Creatively Beth #creativelybeth #toothfairy #fairfieldworld #80daysofpolyfil #polyfil #felt #monster #craft


Once the Tooth Fairy Monster Pillow is stuffed, stitch it closed.

Stitch Tooth Fairy Monster Pillow closed Creatively Beth #creativelybeth #toothfairy #fairfieldworld #80daysofpolyfil #polyfil #felt #monster #craft


Stack a small black button on top of a large colorful button and stitch together with black embroidery floss. Attach the button eyes to the monster with hot glue. This pillow should be used by older children. For smaller children, you can stitch on all elements.

Tooth Fairy Monster Pillow: a 30 Minute DIY with Poly-Fil from Fairfield World

And your Tooth Fairy Monster Pillow is complete.  Aren’t they the cutest things ever?! Get the kiddos involved picking out the colors and buttons, to make it a fun family activity. And, Poly-Fil® from Fairfield World makes the perfect filler! Poly-Fil® has superior resiliency, smooth consistency, is hypo-allergenic, and unconditionally guaranteed.

Tooth Fairy Monster Pillow for Boys and Girls with FREE Patterns Creatively Beth #creativelybeth #toothfairy #fairfieldworld #80daysofpolyfil #polyfil #felt #monster #craft

This year Poly-Fil® is CELEBRATING it’s 80th Anniversary with 80 Days of Poly-Fil® projects. Check out the Fairfield World Instagram account daily to see all of the fabulous projects! I hope you will use my Tooth Fairy Monster Pillow stuffed with Poly-Fil® project as a jumping-off point to showcase your creativity and create something fun and colorful with the kiddos today!  Switch up the colors to match YOUR child’s favorites or add additional embroidery stitches to create a handmade keepsake, the possibilities are endless!

If you liked this project, click through to my Denim Pumpkins with Recycled Jeans which are also stuffed with Poly-Fil® from Fairfield World!

How to Create Denim Pumpkins with Recycled Jeans Creatively Beth #creativelybeth #upcycle #recycle #denim #crafts #falldecor #pumpkins #autumndecor #diy

Remember, sharing is caring! Pin it now to save it for later and make my Tooth Fairy Monster Pillow soon!

Tooth Fairy Monster Pillow for Boys and Girls with FREE Patterns Creatively Beth #creativelybeth #toothfairy #fairfieldworld #80daysofpolyfil #polyfil #felt #monster #craft

Thanks for stopping by!

12 thoughts on “Tooth Fairy Monster Pillow for Boys and Girls with FREE Patterns

  • These are so cute and colorful! I love them!

    • Thanks a bunch, Susie!!

  • That’s the cutest Monster I’ve ever seen Beth. What a fun idea for the little ones and now you have me wishing my two were still toddlers.

    • Thanks, Michelle! This is an idea that I have had for the longest time, so all but one of the kiddos in my life are no too old as well!

  • These are so cute! Thanks for sharing the tutorial. Visiting today from the Party in your PJs link up!

    • Thanks Marielle!!

  • This is the cutest idea! Thanks for sharing this week at Charming Homes & Gardens!

    • Thanks for hosting, Kristin!!

  • Thanks for sharing your cute tooth fairy pillows at Vintage Charm!

    • Thanks for hosting at Vintage Charm, Cecilia!!

    • Thank you for hosting the Embracing Home and Family party, Jennifer!!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *